He is more like a scientist observing himself with removed objectiveness than a human being dealing with this life. I guess this is why New Calvinist like Driscoll have such a hard time with poetry which deals with the subjective heart and emotions, up close and personal.
Monday, March 5, 2012
New Calvinism Akin to Christian Vulcanism?
Part 5 of New Calvinism for Dummies made me ask this of Paul Dohse. His answer was, yes. The New Calvinist works very hard to remove himself from,... uhm, himself, especially his emotional self, to make himself an objective observer of his life so he can deal with his issues.
Labels:
Apollonian,
Mark Driscoll,
New Calvinism,
Star Trek,
Structures
Saturday, March 3, 2012
Mars Hill Calls for Reconciliation. Whatever.
Does it sound like I have a bad attitude. Sorry. I openly confess that I do. You see, the cat is out of the bag. Their abusive practices are being exposed for what they are and they are scrambling for whatever damage control they can get.
Here is what they have posted on their blog:
They say they wish to reconcile but it is a reconciliation on their terms and for their benefit to stop the accusations. It's not about changing their abusive practices or even examining their practices to see if they are abusive.
Oh, they also have a word to their Critics. Since I would fall in that category I thought I'd address it.
"To our critics, we'd humbly ask you to imagine how complicated situations such as this are for us. When someone says they have a issue with us, they get to tell the media their side of the story. If we tell the other side of the story, we risk breaching laws and exposing people-both the people in the discipline process and the people they've sinned against-to public backlash. The choice for us as a church is often to either take the hits in the in the press or put one of our members forward (often a young woman sexually sinned against) to let our members take the hits and endure the criticism. Obviously, we'd rather take the hits as a church than expose our members to the media and potentially break the law by divulging private information shared in counseling session by a victim." -- The Mars Hill Pastors
Sigh.
Dear Mars Hill Pastors...
I'm sorry but I fail to see where you only have the two choices of either silently taking the hits or hiding behind the skirts of women who you claim have been sexually sinned against (whether they were sinned against or not is not the issue. They may very well have been. The very fact that you bring them up in order for you to hide behind is very telling.).
Okay... I understand that you truly believe with all of your hearts that you are doing church discipline right. I get the fact that you believe you are right. Your "A Call for Reconciliation" reeks with the fact that you believe that you are right and that everyone else is wrong.
But could it be that perhaps you are not right and that your church discipline practices have gone in a bad direction?
I understand that thinking this way probably hurts your brains because you are so sure you are right.
But I humbly ask you to consider the possibility that perhaps you all are not as right as you think you are.
I humbly ask you to consider a third choice that would make you look just a little less self-righteous and leave women who have been sinned against out of the equation so that you don't look like you are hiding behind their skirts.
I humbly ask you this, not because I have a vendetta against you or am out to get you or am bored and looking for a fight that doesn't belong to me.
I'm asking because people are being hurt and thrown away and it's making you look bad.
I don't want you to look bad.
I want you to be a light in Seattle and in your satellite churches. I want you to bring the gospel to hurting people and get them healed rather than be the ones that are hurting people so that they have to go to counselling to get healing.
Mars Hill Pastors, please, please, please consider a third choice. Please consider that perhaps there is something wrong with the way you do church. I understand that you don't think so. But the incredible volume of evidence against you speaks otherwise.
KOMO News Seattle, Mars Hill
I wasn't going to publish this. But I see that it has disappeared from other places. This is several days old so not cutting edge at all. Just for the sake of posterity and convenience for finding it, here it is:
Friday, March 2, 2012
New Calvinism Denies the New Creation
II Corinthians 5:17 Therefore if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creature; old things have passed away; behold, new things have come.
When listening to New Calvinists, they talk a lot about the total depravity of mankind.
This next installment of New Calvinism for Dummies, by Paul Dohse, explains how their doctrine doesn't accept that a person can be a new creature in Christ but rather remains totally depraved.
Thursday, March 1, 2012
New Calvinism Is Infiltrating My Church
No, you don't understand. It's not some big metro church up on the latest Christian fads. My church is just a little country church with good down to earth people. Okay, maybe you do understand and I'm just overreacting.
Whichever, this is the reason I'm driven to learn about New Calvinism.
A young man that I've know forever went away to college and now he's quoting Piper instead of the Bible. He's also the youth pastor. I like this young man. He's intelligent, thoughtful, and empathetic. Yet, a couple weekends ago he went up to Seattle on business and visited Mars Hill. Can you hear that loud sucking sound of him being sucked in?
He got this from college. He went to school a born again, professing christian and came back quoting Piper. Which leads me to believe that New Calvinists aren't getting new converts as much as stealing other people's sheep.
And through this wonderful young man, my church is being infiltrated. Now people in my church are carrying ESVs including the Senior Pastor. It is nothing short of insidious.
Also, something else you may not know about me. Even though I lean strongly Egalitarian, my church isn't. They only have male elders and deacons. But they get so many other things right, I just sort of overlook this issue. It's a "Love covers a multitude of sins" thing. Hard to explain.
But if New Calvinism takes over my church, then I'll have to leave. Part of me wants to just leave without a fight cause I don't feel up to it. Part of me knows that I need to have an explanation ready if I make that choice.
Thus, my quest to understand New Calvinism. I want to be able to give an answer to those who ask.
Wednesday, February 29, 2012
Driscoll and Piper are New Calvinists
This is why I'm working toward an understanding of New Calvinism.
New Calvinism is an intricate and elusive intellectual puzzle to me, far removed from the simplicity of the Gospel. It is not traditional Calvinism and has it's beginnings in the 20th century.
And from what I gather, so far, New Calvinism seems to be a reaction against an earlier move in Christianity. I find this to be very interesting since new Calvinists use the ESV translation as other groups use the King James version. And the ESV is a reactionary translation against the TNIV and I have been very concerned about men holding up and practically worshiping a translation that's a reaction against another. How objective is a reaction?
So I keep working, slowly but surely, towards an understanding of this new doctrine that is greatly troubling modern Christendom and the world.
Tuesday, February 28, 2012
Working Toward Understanding Neo-Calvinism
All righty then.
I was commenting on another blog (TWW) and met a fellow, Paul Dohse, who said he would dump everything he knows about Neo-Calvinism in the lap of anyone who emailed him.
I told him that five years of research would over whelm me and that what I really needed was Neo-Calvinism for Dummies.
So he threw something together for me. It is very basic and starts near the beginning of how Neo-Calvinism got started. One of the reasons I am paying attention to Paul is because Cindy Kunsman featured his book on her blog.
Anyway, I thought I'd go ahead and share the link with you:
Saturday, February 25, 2012
The Good News in the Face of Hate
I went to youtube to find some sort of uplifting video to share after my particularly negative previous post. I was actually looking for one in particular that goes through and lists the negative things historic men have said against women through the ages and then God's response in His word set to music.
It was an uplifting video even though it is honest about misogyny through the ages.
Well, I couldn't find it.
So, instead, I'm going to post a link to Cheryl's testimony of the opposition against her ministry, not by men, but by a woman who is misogynous (yes, they exist). It's sad to see the lengths people will go to oppose women. But it is also good to see the truth triumph in the end.
Hating People Out Loud
You know, I usually don't doubt whether a person is an actual Christian or not. Like, say, Mark Driscoll. This man upsets me. Often. But I still believe that he loves Jesus. I don't question his salvation.
Recently I've come across a couple links by men who, straight up, hate women and aren't afraid to show it.
WARNING: Don't go to those links if they will trigger you.
I only link them as proof that a person can be this deceived and actually believe that they are okay with God and that God agrees with their misogyny and hatred.
It's reading things like this (which I don't do often and for good reason) that makes me really wonder if a person has actually given their hearts to Jesus. Because, you see, there is nothing in what they say that represents the Jesus spoken of in the Gospels. It seems that the only thing the Christian Religion is to them is a means by which to add emphasis to their practice of hating people out loud.
You might think that what these men say would enrage me. It really doesn't. Not because shocked and angry aren't appropriate responses. No, rather, I'm concerned for their very souls that are at war within them. I'm concerned about the deception that causes them to rage in the darkness. I'm concerned about the brokenness and deep bitterness in their hearts that requires that they find a scapegoat (women) to rail against. It makes me sad for them to see the depths to which they have fallen. If they actually do make it into heaven, I don't think that they would be comfortable there.
Again, follow these links only if you can go there without their words getting under your skin. And if you do follow them, keep in mind that these men heap judgement upon themselves because, by the measure they judge others, they, themselves, will be judged. May they escape the pit that they have fallen into and find true freedom in the God they falsely represent.
(Edited to add: I realize that the subject matter of this post is extremely toxic and promotes hate, bitterness, and spiritual death. I hope to post something more uplifting soon. Just bear with me as I learn to glance at the deep and severe bitterness of broken and wounded men without feeding into it or returning curses upon those who spew out curses. It's a step we all have to take at one time or another. Some of us are ready for it. Others are not and must heal some more before they can deal with it.)
Edited again to state that the link, "A Woman's Place" was someone's colorful interpretation of what a certain hateful preacher said and not what an actual Christian said. So I removed it and replaced it with another link. Thanks for the heads up from Retha and the confirmation from Anne.
Also, I put this in the comment section to Retha, but decide to go ahead and put it here so people can link it directly. The blog itself is a good, though now inactive, blog. But what it talks about and some of the comments display this hatred and misogyny we see by those who profess to be Christian.
Wednesday, February 22, 2012
I Get Cranky With Driscoll, [Ever notice ? ;) ]
But even though I get very cranky with him over many issues, I still know he's my brother in Christ and I have to remind myself that he's not evil incarnate. He'd just made many mistakes and is under a good deal of self-delusion.
Anyway, because I have to pull back and regroup and remind myself and my readers that Driscoll is not evil, I like to include critiques of him and/or his teaching by those who are either more objective than I, or have a better understanding of the Mars Hill culture through personal experience, or both.
That's why I had guest posts by WTH here and also why I'm linking this, a review of Driscoll's "Real Marriage" book by people who went to church at Mars Hill during the times Driscoll describes in the book. So here it is:
Then also, here are WTH thoughts on this review.
Labels:
Abuse,
Another Blog,
Grace Driscoll,
Links,
Mark Driscoll
Monday, February 20, 2012
"Driscoll Uses the Bible as a Sock Puppet...
...that always agrees with him."--Nick Bulbeck.
A quote so brilliant I wish I had come up with it. But, of course, I didn't. Nor can I take credit for discovering this quote. WTH did. So I'm going to link his post where he quotes the entire paragraph, with contains other insightful things. And WTH's post links the link to this comment so, if you care to, you can read the comment in its in entirety and see the blog from whence it came.
(For those interested this comment was under one kinnon.tv's blog posts)
Saturday, February 18, 2012
A Couple More Chime In On Driscoll
Here are a couple more blog posts on the abuse and UnChristlike happenings going on at Mars Hill.
This one at The Falcon by Taylor Svendsen"
And this one by Christian Piatt at his blog:
Here is a quote I like from Christian Piatt's Post:
"What’s more disturbing to me than all of the bullying, name-calling and shaming, sadistic tactics employed by the church leadership is that so many seem to accept this as a proper way to act as church to one another. Where is the grace? Where is the offer to help the couple reconcile or part peacefully? There’s not even a hint of the old draconian “love the sinner, hate the sin” ethos. It’s more like “hate the sin, abuse the sinner and shame him back into conformity.”
Christian Pratt wants to know where the grace is. I can't answer that.
But I'll tell you what the evidence says about where Grace Driscoll is.
(Another quote from Piatt's post):
"...as senior pastor Mark Driscoll often proclaims from the pulpit, women are 'inferior weaker vessels.' Women, in their inferior state, can’t be expected to be held accountable in the same way as men, who always bear the burden of forced aggression. Period."
(Mara again. Having trouble making blogger behave and take away the white space behind the letters)
Grace is in a weakened and inferior position force upon her by the relentless bullying of her husband. Grace is nothing but a shell of herself, an obedient little doll who knows how to display her plastic, little smile and nod her submissive, little head on cue in order to prop up her husband's raging ego and to keep the charade up of "Happy couple, Happy family, Happy church" going indefinitely. She must do this so that they can pay the light bill and she can go to the gym so she can be, "Hot, hot, hot!" for the man who owns and dominates her.
I could be wrong about this, of course. But this is what most all of the evidence strongly points to.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)